Home
 /
Papers
 /
Cell Biology
 /
Molecular basis for cellular compartmentalization by an ancient membrane fission mechanism
Preprint
Open access
V1
Top 1% · Validated by QED

Molecular basis for cellular compartmentalization by an ancient membrane fission mechanism

Javier Espadas, Diorge P. Souza, Markku Hakala +11 more
November 2025
 ·
bioRxiv
 ·
DOI 
10.1101/2025.11.28.690958
94
%
Reproducible
QED Impressions
This paper passed independent validation.
QED's automated review checked the evidence supporting each claim, the statistical methods, and whether the results are reproducible from the data provided.

It ranks in the top 1% of preprints assessed in Cell Biology this quarter.
Run full QED analysis
Read paper
Save

Why this is interesting

Identifying Hofund—an archaeal amphipathic helix sufficient to drive membrane fission and restore eukaryotic ESCRT-III in vivo—proves fission predates eukaryogenesis and reframes the complexity of eukaryotic compartmentalization as diversification of a primordial mechanism.

QED claims analysis

Summary

ESCRT-III-mediated membrane fission is an ancestral activity predating eukaryogenesis, executed through a conserved N-terminal amphipathic helix (Hofund) that drives fission via deep membrane insertion and lipid destabilization in Asgard archaea, with this mechanism preserved but fragmented across multiple eukaryotic ESCRT-III paralogs that cooperatively reconstitute the ancestral fission trigger during intraluminal vesicle formation.

See full analysis
Main Claim 1 –

Heimdall ESCRT-IIIA drives fission via ATP-dependent subunit turnover

Supporting evidence

  • Negatively curved lipids enhance ESCRT-IIIA fission by promoting packing defects
Main Claim 2 –

N-terminal Hofund α10 helix is required for ESCRT-IIIA fission

Main Claim 3 –

Hofund alone triggers fission by deep insertion and lipid disorder

Main Claim 4 –

Eukaryotic Hofund elements are required for ESCRT-III fission in vivo

Supporting evidence

  • Eukaryogenesis duplicated and fragmented Hofund across A-type ESCRT-III paralogs
  • Heimdall Hofund rescues eukaryotic fission defects at terminal assembly step

Abstract

The emergence of cell compartmentalization depends on membrane fission to create the endomembrane compartments. In eukaryotes, membrane fission is commonly executed by ESCRT-III, a protein complex conserved in all domains of life. However, whether membrane fission was an ancestral ESCRT-III activity predating eukaryogenesis remains unknown. Here we show that ESCRT-IIIA from Asgard Heimdallarchaeota, the closest archaeal relatives of eukaryotes, performs membrane fission through an N-terminal amphipathic helix, which we term Hofund. In eukaryotes, Hofund is fragmented across ESCRT-IIIA paralogs, and disrupting these regions causes severe fission defect in yeast. Remarkably, Heimdallarchaeota Hofund restores fission when fused to defective eukaryotic paralogs. These findings suggest that ESCRT-III-mediated fission arose before eukaryogenesis and later diversified to support the regulatory complexity of eukaryotic compartmentalization.

Related papers

How the QED Score works

QED Score is a validated AI-based quality metric that evaluates life science papers on two dimensions: originality and validity. Each manuscript is anonymized, broken down into its claims and supporting evidence, and examined by specialized AI agents for statistical rigor, consistency across figures, and fit with the existing literature. Scores are percentile ranks, so they're comparable across fields. In blinded tests, expert professors sided with QED Score over journal rank in 75% of decisive cases.
Read the methodology

Free access for academic researchers

Create your free QED account to validate your research, strengthen grant proposals, and uncover scientific insights.
We've sent you an access link.
Please check your inbox.

Didn't get your email? Check your spam folder or reach out to info@qedscience.com

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Looking for QED for pharma, biotech or life science organizations?